DISAPPEARING KLEIN! Naomi Klein mocked Larry Summersand a question popped into our heads: // link // print // previous // next //
TUESDAY, APRIL 21, 2009
A vastly changed world: Last Saturday, we were struck by Ellen McCarthys front-page piece in the Washington Post. And well admit it: We were moved by the piece again as we reread it this morning. It deals with the Washington areas (admittedly silly) childrenin particular, with its tween girls. Yes, those kids can be pretty silly. But we think the piece is worth pondering.
We wouldnt have published this piece ourselves; wed be concerned that it would do harm to the two children who lie at its core. That said, the piece was publishedand we thought it described a vastly changed world.
Race is rarely mentioned herebut for us, the topic informed our reactions. McCarthy discusses a bunch of area girlssome of them white and some of them black. Perusing the tidbits in her report, wed guess that their worlds are all vastly changed from the worlds of their parents and grandparents.
A note about Caprice Humphreys, the fifth-grade poet who lists some of the ways she has been inspired. (On-line, her actual poem has been dumped.) Silly though such kids may be, fifth-graders long for inspiration. We wish the stars of our pseudo-prog world would give them a bit more to shoot for.
Disappearing Klein: In Sundays Outlook section, the Washington Post featured a special spring cleaning feature. Ten prominent people were asked to name something the world could afford to throw out.
We were struck by Naomi Kleins selectionshe wants to throw out Larry Summers! Heres how she started:
In the course of a short, witty piece, Kleins reviews a string of major bungles she attributes to bubble-brain Summers. And that's the problem with Larry, she writes. For all his appeals to absolute truths, he has been spectacularly wrong again and again.
Is Klein right about Summers? Here at THE HOWLER, we arent really sure. But as we read Kleins piece, a question wormed its way into our mind: How often has Naomi Klein been featured on our progressive news programs? Why dont we ever seem to see her on Countdown? On the Maddow show?
With respect to that initial question, the answer would seem to be: Once. According to the Nexis archives, Klein has never appeared on the Maddow show. She has appeared on Countdown exactly onceon November 29, 2007, when she appeared to discuss her new book, The Shock Doctrine. You may recall the odd, sad moment mid-way through as Olbermann teased two reports:
Look whos talking, our analysts mordantly said. See THE DAILY HOWLER, 11/30/07.
At any rate, Olbermann did a short segment with Kleinand shes never been seen on his program again. For the record, heres how that segment ended:
Let the party begin! There he went again.
We have no idea why Klein hasnt been back on either of our progressive news programs. (We have no idea if she has been asked.) But her Post piece dealt with a serious topic. Wed love to see qualified people like Klein asked to discuss Summers recordand the possible meaning of his prominence within the Obama Admin.
Kleins Outlook piece was witty, but it dealt with a serious topic. Then too, we got this piece of hackneyed pap from the brilliant Ana Marie Cox, whose fatuous nonsense you get served about twice a week now on Maddow. You see, regarding that spring cleaning chore, Cox would throw out the White House press corps! In her piece, she makes a modestly valid but hackneyed point. Indeed, her point has been modestly valid but hackneyed for years, as various hacks keep retyping it.
You never see Kleinbut you always see Cox! Is there any chance you dont see Klein because shes just too g*ddamn smart? Because she isnt good with dick jokes? Wont stoop to the level of juvenile insult? Because she isnt a clowning Potemkinan entertainer, of the kind GE likes?
Because she wont stuff her pockets with corporate cash by pretending to stage real discussions?
Why hasnt Klein been back? We dont have the slightest idea.
Our progressive programs disgraced themselves in the past two weeks, as the clan gazed silently on. Next week, we plan to start a series of posts on the people behind this rank clowning. Who is Bill Wolff, well incomparably ask. How about their own Richard Wolffe? And perhaps even this: What sorts of things might a skeptic notice in the worlds many profiles of Maddow?
Meanwhile, whats the story with Larry Summers? What might his current prominence tell us about Obama? For ourselves, we have no real idea. Beyond that, we dont expect to see this topic discussed on our clowning news programs.
Ana Marie will be back, of coursefull of her risque inanity. So it goes as we liberal rubes get sold the illusion of discourse.
Who is Bill Wolff, well incomparably ask. Whose vision is shaping these programs?
(Note: Based on our past observations, Bill Wolff has a good sense of humor.)