A LONG AND WINDING ROAD! We think our liberal shows are a wreck. But how can we best explain that? // link // print // previous // next //
FRIDAY, MARCH 27, 2009
A long and winding road: Weve spent a lot of time today trying to continue yesterdays discussion. Lets say it again: At present, we think the disintegration of our liberal cable programs is the most important story in media. But we want to tell that story with care. And frankly, we find these programs so appalling its rather hard to do.
For that reason, were going to wait until were less repulsed by what appears on our screen at night.
That said, lets offer this:
As noted yesterday, Rachel Maddow offered a superlative, deeply informative segment on Wednesday evenings program (see THE DAILY HOWLER, 3/26/09). Steve Benen seemed to have a similar reaction. Just click here.
Maddow interviewed Senator Byron Dorgan (D-ND) about the 1999 Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act, an important measure which (Maddows words) removed a Great Depression-era regulation that had said that banks and investment banks and insurance companies all had to be separate. Dorgan was one of only eight senators who voted against the bill, which opened the door to some of the financial disasters with which we are now engaged. This bill will, in my judgment, raise the likelihood of future massive taxpayer bailouts, Dorgan said on the Senate floor early in the legislative process. When the bill finally passed in November, he said this to the New York Times: I think we will look back in 10 years' time and say, 'We should not have done this.
As she was closing the segment, Maddow praised Dorgan for his pre-vision. And Dorgan said something important:
We need prosecutions, Dorgan said, and we need to restore regulation. But we need something else, the senator said: We need the narrative of what happened so that everybody understands what happened. Citizens need to understand the process by which we got into our messes. Maddows segment with Dorgan that night surely aided that process.
Maddows session with Dorgan was superbtightly focused, highly informative. But its amazing how rarely youll see such segments on the nightly cable news programs which are driven by liberal/progressive outlooks. Such segments almost never occur on Countdownand theyre amazingly rare on The Rachel Maddow Show. On Wednesday, for example, Maddow played it real tough about those conservaDemsthen meekly refused to ask real questions when conservaDem Jeanne Shaheen appeared.
We got turned on by all her tough talkand then, we got left with nothing.
Our nation is badly in need of narratives of what happened (or is happening). But lets be honest: That simply isnt what these two increasingly useless programs are about.
What are these two liberal programs about? Were going to take a bit more care as we try to answer that question. But the mainstream press press corps is very weakand the conservative world is a screaming joke. If we dont informed by progressive media, we simply wont get informed at all. And this nation is going to die if it gets any more dumb.
As Dorgan said: We badly need narrativesreal understanding. In our view, these liberal programs rarely provide that. They serve us comfort foodand jokes. And sometimes, they lie in our faces. We think of a clowning host last night as we make that unfortunate statement.
For what its worth: In todays Post, Al Kamen more or less acknowledges that his poorly-reported story was pure perfect crap. Reports of the Long Wars Death Were Apparently Premature, his headline reads. This story was so dumb and so convoluted that we wont attempt to summarize it here; see THE DAILY HOWLER, 3/25/09, for our original treatment. But Hannity and Beck have pimped it all weekand a liberal host swallowed it whole Tuesday night. Go aheadread through the transcript. Dont forget to enjoy all the jokes.
Kamen corrects himself today. We wonder if Maddow will? On a simple factual basis, her report was more bogus than Kamens.
She played the story for good solid laughs. Increasingly, clowning and comfort food is what these liberal shows are about. We get to clown around with our liberal pals. They tell us how dumb the other tribe is.
That segment with Dorgan was very smart. Such work is amazingly rare.
Why would anyone pay attention to Kamen: Kamen earned his bones on Christmas Eve 1999 as Americas number-one Christmas card critic. What a surprise! The Gore familys Christmas card showed that Gore was a fake! No, we really arent making it up; see THE DAILY HOWLER, 12/24/99. Why would any liberal show pay attention to this vintage nut?